MLS #43028
Edgartown Real Estate

Photo 1 of 34
Photo 2 of 34
Photo 3 of 34
Photo 4 of 34
Photo 5 of 34
Photo 6 of 34
Photo 7 of 34
Photo 8 of 34
Photo 9 of 34
Photo 10 of 34
Photo 11 of 34
Photo 12 of 34
Photo 13 of 34
Photo 14 of 34
Photo 15 of 34
Photo 16 of 34
Photo 17 of 34
Photo 18 of 34
Photo 19 of 34
Photo 20 of 34
Photo 21 of 34
Photo 22 of 34
Photo 23 of 34
Photo 24 of 34
Photo 25 of 34
Photo 26 of 34
Photo 27 of 34
Photo 28 of 34
Photo 29 of 34
Photo 30 of 34
Photo 31 of 34
Photo 32 of 34
Photo 33 of 34
Photo 34 of 34
COMING SOON — SHOWINGS BEGIN APRIL 4, 2025 Set on a beautifully landscaped half-acre in Katama, this thoughtfully reimagined ranch is just a short bike ride to South Beach or downtown Edgartown. The main house features 2 bedrooms, 1.5 baths, and a bright, open layout with a fully renovated kitchen (2020) showcasing quartz countertops, stainless appliances, and a serene coastal palette. The full bath was tastefully updated in 2024 with modern, high-end finishes. The home is also supported by a 4-bedroom septic system, offering flexibility for future expansion or guest accommodations. A partially finished lower level in the main house adds approximately 550 sq ft of bonus living space — perfect for guest overflow, a playroom, or home office. Outdoor living is a highlight — enjoy a screened porch, a sun-drenched back deck, and a picturesque pergola patio, ideal for gatherings or quiet island mornings. A separate, handcrafted post-and-beam barn built in 2014 offers a flexible guest retreat. The 450 sq ft loft glows with exposed beams and natural woodwork, while the 720 sq ft lower level includes manufactured wood flooring and a built-in bar for effortless entertaining. All of this is nestled among mature trees and lush green lawn, offering privacy, charm, and true Vineyard living. Please see the full list of upgrades attached to the listing. A pre-listing home inspection is available upon request. Owners are in residence — no drive-bys, and advanced notice for showings is preferred
Share
Price:  $2,195,000
17 Suttons Way
Edgartown, 02568
Type: Single Family
Beds: 3
Baths: 1.0
Lot Size: 0.50 acres
Square Footage: 1746 sqft.
Area
Edgartown
Subdivision
Katama
Zoning
R20
Water
Town
Sewer
Septic
Year Built
1985
Year Renovated
2017
Second Dwelling
Existing
Furnished
Un-Furnished
Rooms
9
Half Baths
1
First Floor Bedrooms
2
Fireplaces
0
Flooring
Hardwood
Heating
Heat Pump
Yard
yes
Foundation
Poured
Outdoor Spaces
Deck
Parking
Ample
Dishwasher
Kitchen-aid
Dryer
na
Refrigerator
Kitchen-aid
Stove
Kitchen-aid Electric
TV
Cable
Washer
na
Listing Agent
Crissman, Carson
Listing Office
Compass | Point B